Seems like it
I'm amazed that people would pay money to go see something like that (laughs)
Because they're a dance unit
Because the quality is high
- きゃりーとPerfumeは口パクがキャラクターの一部になってるから生歌なのが想像できないレベルBecause lip-syncing is part of Kyary's and Perfume's image.
They're on a level already where you can't even imagine them singing live.
Anyone can dance as long as you practice so it doesn't have to be specifically those three.
- きゃりーとかAKBよりはマシってことだろIt's because we'd rather have them than Kyary and AKB.
- 歌うまいのにわざとやってるんだからポリシーなんだろThey're good singers, but they're just doing that on purpose.
It's their policy.
Because they're the best lip-syncers. Can't be helped.
They actually sang quite a lot when I saw them at the dome a while back
- アイドルは可愛くても忘れられる子は沢山居るそれよりも認識されて個性的な方が重要Perfumeは髪型で認識されるほど個性的だから強いThere are a lot of idols who may be cute but are still forgettable.
It's more important to be recognized and to distinguish yourself from the rest.
Each perfume member has her own distinct personality, so much so that they're even known now for their respective hairstyles.
I've never heard Perfume singing live. It seems that they did so before, though.
- これでもどれが誰か分かるって凄いよなｗAnd it's amazing that you still know who each member is even with this one.
One of their strengths is that they can easily be turned into manga.
They've been exiled from the FNS Kayousai, right?
- FNSから追放すべきなのは歌が下手なくせに無理矢理生歌で視聴者不快にしてる小便糞アイドルだろｗ実力者集められずに何が生歌至上主義だよThe ones who should be banned from FNS are the piss-poor idols who make viewers feel uncomfortable with their horrible live singing.
That program couldn't even assemble the really talented singers, and they're making performers sing live just for the sake of it.
If it wasn't for Yasutaka, this is how they would have become
Maybe A-chan's actually a good singer?
Kyary's lip-syncing is being criticized, though
- (Related post HERE and HERE)
I wonder what the difference between Perfume and Kyary is?
Looking totally like underground idols
I think Perfume's the only group who still has these videos from their development years.
They're better than the other idols now
- CD音源聴かされて全く面白くないんだけどパフォーマンス集団みたいI'm totally not amused by them, they just make me listen to music in their CDs when they perform.
They're just a "performance group".
They sang quite a lot at the dome, though
Who cares about stories of their Dome concert, it won't even be seen by the vast majority of the public
- どうでもいい生歌もダンスも上手いだけでは表舞台に出れない人なんて掃いて捨てるほど居るI don't care.
There are a ton of people who are good at singing live and at dancing, but couldn't even break into the scene.
- パフュだけ名誉口パク扱いの音楽ヲタはなんなんだWhat's with these music-wotas who are regarding Perfume differently and saying that they're like honorary lip-syncers?
Like Idol Master w
- 脳内で変換されてるから毎回違って聴こえるんだよそのぐらいのめり込めるって素敵なことじゃないかTheir voices are being switched in my head so they sound differently each time.
I think it's wonderful how people can feel absorbed like that with them.
- 業界だとAKBの口パクはネタにしてもおｋPerfumeきゃりーは今後の仕事に影響が出るジャニーズは知られた次の日に業界から消される こんな認識ですねBut in the industry it's like:
AKB even allows their lip-syncing to be made fun of.
For Perfume and Kyary, it will have a negatibe effect on their work.
But if they find out about Johnny's, you'll be erased from the industry the next day.
Something like this?
- ももクロの歌声も10代だから笑って済ましてるだけで無理して歌わせる方もどうかしてるレベル聴いてる人を不快にするなら口パクの方がマシだと思うBut I honestly feel that there's also something wrong with those who are making girls like MomoClo sing live. They're just laughing off their live singing just because they're in their teens.
I personally think that lip-syncing is much better than making people feel unpleasant by being forced to listen to their horrible voices.
- スタイル良い美人3人がプロのダンスを見せつつ愉快なトークと綺麗な歌声を披露しながら最先端テクノロジーの演出が堪能するIt's all about enjoying these 3 stylish beauties talking delightfully and showcasing their professional dancing skills and pretty voices together with cutting-edge technology
Lip-syncing is acceptable in Perfume's and Kyary's musical style.
Perfume are the perfect idols who project this high quality of art through the synchronization of their honed sound and visuals
Perfume's lip-sync is beautiful
- Perfume最新ライブ行ったけどポイントジェニーはご機嫌ななめDream Land辺りは完全生歌だったなI went to Perfume's latest concert and they sang these songs entirely live:
Jenny wa gokigen naname
They're the group who started lip-syncing
- ムリに下手な生歌にこだわる必要ないよ素材に過ぎないんだからwThere's no need to be too particular with live singing anyway.
They're just "materials" afterall w
- ももクロに限らず下手でも一生懸命歌ってくれるアイドルは良いねAKBやPerfumeのような口パク目の前でやられると萎えるIt's not just limited to MomoClo, but I like idols who give their all and sing live even if they're bad.
I'd be turned off when I see lip-syncing like AKB and Perfume right in front of my eyes.
- AKBPerfumeのヲタはエ口目線だから口パクでも気にしないそもそも気づいてないAKB and Perfume wotas look at these idols with perverted eyes so they don't mind lip-syncing.
Rather, they don't even notice it.
For Perfume, it's part of their musicality so it can't be helped
- パフュームのパは口パクのパPafyu~mu's "Pa" is the "Pa" of Kuchipaku
* Kuchipaku = lipsync
They're good at lip-syncing
- 口パクがうまいのは認める間違いなく日本一I agree that they're good at lip-syncing.
They're undoubtedly #1 in Japan in that aspect.