- "They came out with a lot of songs that I liked." (22/M)
- "I listened to them a lot when I was a student." (25/F)
- "There are times when I feel like listening to them again." (24/M)
5. FUNKY MONKEY BABYS (11)
- "I still want to listen to their new songs." (24/F)
- "I feel warm just by listening to their songs." (22/F)
- "I really like how FunMon rouses people up." (22/F)
- "I'm sad that they split up. Instead of going solo, I hope they all come back together again at least once when they find the time." (27/F)
4. 19 (12)
- "They were with me through my youth." (27/M)
- "I liked the songs and the voice. I listened to them a lot in Jr. High and they bring back memories." (27/F)
- "I think they're on par with Yuzu as this great duo who sang youthful songs." (26/F)
- "So nostalgic." (31/F)
(Top 3 after the jump)
Source:
- "I want to listen to Himuro's live singing with Hotei's guitar playing." (31/M)
- "They're cool." (42/M)
- "I want to listen to them again." (40/M)
- "I used to listen to them a lot." (33/M)
2. THE YELLOW MONKEY (15)
- "A band I used to listen to a lot in high school, and pretty much defined my youth." (32/M)
- "Kazuya Yoshii is still cool up to now, and I was a fan when I was in Jr. High." (29/M)
- "Because they have a lot of songs that echo in your heart." (29/M)
- "They were unique, I liked them." (28/F)
1. JUDY AND MARY (60)
- "I was still a kid when they were popular and I wasn't able to go to their concerts then. I want to go this time." (26/F)
- "I want them to sing their hit songs, and I want to listen to new songs!" (30/F)
- "Because YUKI-chan is cute." (43/M)
- "I want to see how the current YUKI-san would sing their earlier songs which were girly and energetic." (35/M)
- "I have a lot of fond memories about them from my youth." (37/M)
http://static1.wikia.nocookie.net/__cb20090422030726/j__/judyandmary/images/5/5b/Judy_and_Mary_%285%29.jpg
Other bands that did not make it into the ranking:
BARBEE BOYS
ELLEGARDEN
GARNET CROW
RC Succession
Ulfuls
KICK THE CAN CREW
WANDS
PIERROT
Checkers
Yaen
Pocket Biscuits
- 9: 名無しさん＠恐縮です 2014/02/03(月) 21:06:32.01 ID:E7nbDWBSO
- がっかりするだけだから再結成なんてしなくていい
People will just get disappointed, so there's no need to reunite - 13: 名無しさん＠恐縮です 2014/02/03(月) 21:08:32.53 ID:GMQBQ5+S0
- いえもんがついに2位にきたかこの毎度毎度のランキングでOh, Yellow Monkey finally manages to get 2nd.
In this same old, same old ranking. - 14: 名無しさん＠恐縮です 2014/02/03(月) 21:08:32.59 ID:eL9yBBsHO
- チェッカーズはアイドル路線を捨てなかったせいかえらい過小評価だよな。女の子向けイメージが強すぎて男がファンと表明するのは勇気がいったThe Checkers are underrated because they didn't abandon their idol lineage.
They're strongly associated with female fans, and men needed courage to come out and say that they liked the Checkers. - 16: 名無しさん＠恐縮です 2014/02/03(月) 21:09:29.96 ID:kRqyzjYqO
- 大人になったYUKIさんが、ガーリーでエネルギッシュな初期の楽曲をどう歌うか見てみたい（35歳／男性）こんなこと言う奴ホンマにおるんかい- "I want to see how the current YUKI-san would sing their earlier songs which were girly and energetic." (35/M)
Is there really someone who'd say something like this? - 19: 名無しさん＠恐縮です 2014/02/03(月) 21:09:53.42 ID:RrxqjAR70
- ジュディマリとかイエモンって最後の方意味わからん曲ばっか出してたな解散していくバンドって最後ああなるのが普通なんだなThe songs JudyMary & YeMon released towards their twilight years were incomprehensible.
That must really be what happens when bands are already about to split up. - 29: 名無しさん＠恐縮です 2014/02/03(月) 21:12:14.74 ID:nF6DJn650
- こういうランキングって大抵ブルーハーツ入ってた気がするけど、めずらしく無いな
I always thought that the Blue Hearts would mostly be in rankings like this. It's a surprise that they're not in here. - 30: 名無しさん＠恐縮です 2014/02/03(月) 21:12:26.81 ID:Jn8EYHL40
- JWALKとかSIAM SHADEは復活しないのかね
Won't JWALK and SIAMSHADE come back? - 34: 名無しさん＠恐縮です 2014/02/03(月) 21:13:49.50 ID:PpmcMwm/P
- >>30シャムシェイドは再結成しなかったっけ？Didn't SIAM SHADE make a comeback recently?
(Related post HERE)
http://blog-imgs-53.fc2.com/g/e/i/geitsuboo/Siam_2BShade_2BSSmag7a.jpg - 32: 名無しさん＠恐縮です 2014/02/03(月) 21:13:26.71 ID:OMd1hX0H0
- ＺＯＮＥの最後とか悲惨だったやんｗｗ
But ZONE's final days were pretty tragic ww - 35: 名無しさん＠恐縮です 2014/02/03(月) 21:13:54.00 ID:cyh1fLKO0
- BLINK１８２
- 41: 名無しさん＠恐縮です 2014/02/03(月) 21:15:56.09 ID:i0cu6qjA0
- >>35blinkは普通に活動再開してるよ今年もすでに色んなフェスに出演すること発表されてるしBlink has been playing together again.
They've already been announced to play at a couple of festivals this year. - 167: 名無しさん＠恐縮です 2014/02/03(月) 21:47:23.10 ID:cyh1fLKO0
- >>41そうだったんか！アトム・ウィラードとバンド組んだり、プロデューサー業に専念したり、ドラムの人もなんかやっていたなで止まっていた。Is that so!
My knowledge about them stopped at the point where someone formed a band with Atom Willard, someone focused on producing, and even the drummer did something else, right? - 46: 名無しさん＠恐縮です 2014/02/03(月) 21:17:49.47 ID:jDvL72WM0
- イエモンは新入社員が知らなくて驚いた世代の違いを改めて感じたわI was surprised that a new employee didn't know who the YELLOW MONKEY were.
That once again made me realize the generation gap. - 47: 名無しさん＠恐縮です 2014/02/03(月) 21:17:57.55 ID:9j60benC0
- ZONE入れんな馬鹿やろうｗｗｗｗｗｗｗｗｗｗｗｗもうどうやって再結成するんだよｗｗｗｗｗｗｗｗｗｗｗｗDon't include ZONE here, are you idiots? wwwwwwwwwwwwww
How the heck are they supposed to reunite? wwwwwwwwwwwww - 53: 名無しさん＠恐縮です 2014/02/03(月) 21:19:48.98 ID:9j60benC0
- ああこれ票数少ない地味なアンケなのね
Ah, a plain survey with a low vote count. - 54: 名無しさん＠恐縮です 2014/02/03(月) 21:20:10.02 ID:GkravpPYO
- やっぱビートルズだよ
The Beatles, of course - 56: 名無しさん＠恐縮です 2014/02/03(月) 21:20:35.21 ID:fKkTXtbZ0
- 震災のどさくさで色んなバンド復活したけど、別にがっかりはなかったよ。懐かしいことをしてくれるだけで、もう十分すぎるくらい堪能できる。A lot of bands came back to play together again after the disaster, but they didn't really disappoint.
Them doing all those nostalgic things was already satisfying in itself.
- 64: 名無しさん＠恐縮です 2014/02/03(月) 21:21:54.87 ID:eYO2Ljs50
- >・YUKIちゃんがかわいいから（43歳／男性）再結成する必要あるのかこれ> - "Because YUKI-chan is cute." (43/M)
Do they even need to make a comeback just because of this? - 368: 名無しさん＠恐縮です 2014/02/03(月) 22:38:30.06 ID:PTXzUdxm0
- >>64的確なツッコミでﾜﾛﾀw
LOL that's so spot on w - 68: 名無しさん＠恐縮です 2014/02/03(月) 21:22:42.99 ID:bIQ/WUlv0
- イエモンは復活してほしかったなあ…吉井ソロはイマイチ物足りない
I wanted YeMon to come back... Yoshii's solo efforts just doesn't cut it. - 70: 名無しさん＠恐縮です 2014/02/03(月) 21:23:14.13 ID:zLHX6sIyO
- Janne Da Arc
- 317: 名無しさん＠恐縮です 2014/02/03(月) 22:26:37.85 ID:YSea2NF+0
- >>70解散はしてないけどはげどはげど
I don't think they've disbanded, but I strongly concur - 78: 名無しさん＠恐縮です 2014/02/03 21:25:38 ID:MsengE/10
- ジュディマリは再結成して欲しいバンドじゃなくて、ボーカルに解散前の曲を歌って欲しいバンドだな
Judy and Mary isn't really a band that people want to come back, people just want to make the singer sing the old songs of the band - 82: 名無しさん＠恐縮です 2014/02/03(月) 21:26:38.40 ID:AWKSkrFi0
- ZIG ZAG再結成してくれ
I hope ZIG ZAG comes back - 329: 名無しさん＠恐縮です 2014/02/03(月) 22:29:21.42 ID:cnjMc5uyP
- >>82去年フェスで見たぞ
I saw them at a festival last year - 85: 名無しさん＠恐縮です 2014/02/03(月) 21:26:46.24 ID:yM7OU4U90
- どれも知らない
I don't know any of these - 90: 名無しさん＠恐縮です 2014/02/03(月) 21:28:22.94 ID:K5QbNXL20
- ドリフターズが入ってないなんて
How come Drifters aren't included there? - 91: 名無しさん＠恐縮です 2014/02/03(月) 21:28:41.74 ID:jLNQeIwm0
- フリッパーズ・ギターは僕の青春ぜひ再結成してください最後に歌う曲は「すべての言葉はさよなら」でお願いしますFlippers Guitar defined my youth.
I really hope they come back.
And please play "Subete no kotoba wa sayonara" for your last song - 101: 名無しさん＠恐縮です 2014/02/03 21:31:54 ID:LXtTHChO0
- 年齢と一致しないものをみると親の影響受けてんだろなーとほのぼのする
It's nice when you see these respondents liking bands that don't match their age since you'd come to realize that it was the influence of their parents
- 113: 名無しさん＠恐縮です 2014/02/03(月) 21:35:14.26 ID:bWt5IZbn0
- 珍しく理解できるランキングだわ同意はしかねるけど今再結成してもガッカリするだけだと思うしThis is a ranking that I can understand for a change, but I can't really agree with.
I think that fans will just get disappointed if these bands ever come back. - 122: 名無しさん＠恐縮です 2014/02/03(月) 21:36:29.15 ID:XvRo8dwD0
- イエモンは吉井で持ってると思ったけど吉井ソロがイマイチなのでバンドでしか出せない魅力ってあるんだろうなI always thought that Yoshii was the one who carried YeMon, but seeing how his solo effort didn't make waves, there really must've been something that only the band was able to offer
http://kansai.pia.co.jp/interview/assets_c/2013/02/yoshiikazuya_main-thumb-960x640-7112.jpg - 132: 名無しさん＠恐縮です 2014/02/03(月) 21:38:52.04 ID:MO8oDExp0
- >>122イエモン・吉井のライブ何回も行ってるけどフェスとかだと仕方ないかもしれないけどイエモンの曲の時だけ盛り上がって後は地蔵だもんね悲しいよね
I've been to numerous concerts of YeMon's Yoshii. Although I know it can't be helped, people were jumping and were full of energy when he sang YeMon songs and were just like stone statues during the rest of the time. It's really sad. - 136: 名無しさん＠恐縮です 2014/02/03(月) 21:39:08.91 ID:i0cu6qjA0
- >>122スマパンもやっぱりイハダーシージミーいた頃と今の完全ソロとではなんか違うしなEven the Smashing Pumpkins now are totally different; it's totally just like (Billy Corgan's) solo compared to the time when they had Iha, D'arcy, and Jimmy.
- 168: 名無しさん＠恐縮です 2014/02/03(月) 21:47:23.51 ID:Kxtlquo4O
- >>136スマパン黄金期の面子は余りにエグすぎる全員が神がかってたThe peak of the Smashing Pumpkins was just ruthless.
All the members were like gods. - 125: 名無しさん＠恐縮です 2014/02/03(月) 21:37:27.03 ID:GuPBo0m70
- YUKIにはもうジュディマリ時代の曲は歌えない。残念ながら声が出ない。あの伸びやかな高音はもうなくなってしまったんだよ。ルックスは今のがいいね！YUKI won't be able to sing her Judy and Mary songs anymore.
Too bad but her voice doesn't come out as well.
That stretched high-pitch voice is no more.
But she looks much better now.
http://gdtd.vn/dataimages/201303/original/images659787_18.jpg - 147: 名無しさん＠恐縮です 2014/02/03 21:42:12 ID:dCmUZKw70
- ソロ活動始めたばっかのファンキー加藤全否定かよｗ
So are they completely denying Funky Kato's existence who just started going solo? w
(Related post HERE) - 178: 名無しさん＠恐縮です 2014/02/03 21:50:57 ID:IGbLHXlR0
- 世代の断絶を感じる
I'm feeling the extinction of a generation with this - 186: 名無しさん＠恐縮です 2014/02/03 21:53:33 ID:Ux71MniBP
- ブルーハーツとハイロウズ
クロマニヨンズであの頃の曲やってくれるなら再結成しなくても良いんだけどw
Blue Hearts and High-lows
I'm fine with them not coming back though if they'll be singing their songs back then with the Cromagnons w
http://skream.jp/interview/2013/01/the_cro-magnons.jpg - 190: 名無しさん＠恐縮です 2014/02/03(月) 21:54:20.53 ID:dmWS8Luh0
- 人気のあったバンドってもうほとんど再結成してねえか？
But haven't the popular ones made their comeback already? - 201: 名無しさん＠恐縮です 2014/02/03(月) 21:56:29.60 ID:Tw9suzca0
- >>190キャロル、チェッカーズ、ボウイはまだだよやるとしても全員揃いは不可能なとこばっかあとコンプレックスも布袋が義援金隠しちゃったからもうダメだろThere's still no CAROL, Checkers, and Boowy.
But even if they do, there's no way that they'd be able to gather all the members.
Hotei also hid the donations for the COMPLEX so they won't be able to come back anymore. - 193: 名無しさん＠恐縮です 2014/02/03(月) 21:55:08.47 ID:h8tscU/z0
- 再結成しても客がおっさんとババアばっかりでロックといえるのかねｗ
They will be nothing but grandpas and grandmas when they come back, can you still call that rock? w
http://blog-imgs-53.fc2.com/g/e/i/geitsuboo/_E3_83_81_E3_82_A7_E3_83_83_E3_82_AB_E3_83_BC_E3_82_BA.jpg
いざ再結成されると微妙なんだよね、
やっぱり思い出の中で頑張ってもらったほうがいい場合もある
I'm a LUNA SEA fan and I always wanted them to come back, but when they did, they weren't all that.
There are also times when you'd want your favorites to just keep living on in your memories.
http://media.timeoutsingapore.com/contentFiles/image/2013/2-feb/music/luna-sea-4dfe7614074f6-482x298.jpg
ソロでそこそこ売れてるうちは再結成しない
They'll reunite once they can't sell anymore as solo artists.
They won't if they're still doing well as solo artists.
Super Car, hurry up and reunite
http://blog-imgs-19.fc2.com/c/o/s/cosmicairplaneayako/20080221230451.jpg
もう無理だけどオリジナルの４人で
Michelle Gun Elephant
I don't think it's possible, but please do, with the original 4.
http://www.cdjournal.com/image/jacket/100/Z2/Z226001003.jpg
Yuratei
http://www.d2.dion.ne.jp/~takanomo/LOVELOG_IMG/yurayura051231.jpg
- 381: 名無しさん＠恐縮です 2014/02/03 22:41:20 ID:q8DYrx3U0
- 再結成とかださいことしなくていい
No need to do something so lame like reuniting
- 395: 名無しさん＠恐縮です 2014/02/03 22:44:10 ID:RgW/O1Ks0
- >>381ホントこれにつきる
This so much
ファンも良い思い出として大事にできるけど
本当は解散したくなかったとか、まだまだやりたかったと
消化不良のコメントがあるとファンもやり切れないんだよなぁ…
When the members themselves split up and say that they've done it all, then the fans will be able to treasure those memories and move on.
But when they say stuff like "We really didn't want to split up", "We still wanted to continue", it's also unbearable to the fans.
Original Thread
http://hayabusa3.2ch.net/test/read.cgi/mnewsplus/1391429021/"
No comments:
Post a Comment