18. Others - 398
17. T-BOLAN - 29
16. DIR EN GREY - 35
15. REBECCA - 36
14. LUNA SEA - 79
13. UNICORN - 81
12. PORNO GRAFITTI - 107
11. SPITZ - 122
10. PRINCESS PRINCESS - 131
*9. ONE OK ROCK - 136
*8. GLAY - 298
*7. THE BLUE HEARTS - 351
*6. L'Arc~en~Ciel - 485
>>5 up after the jump
Source:
http://livedoor.blogimg.jp/seasoncolor/imgs/a/c/ac5fa220.JPG
*4. X JAPAN - 1,144
*3. BOOWY - 1,187
*2. SOUTHERN ALL STARS - 1,263
*1. B'z - 2,964
http://www.japantoday.com/images/size/x/2012/08/vermillion.jpg
This isn't good...
What's rock again?
But in reality, B'z are actually better than the foreign acts, especially when you see them at festivals
ほぼロックバンドじゃない件
Most of those aren't even "Rock bands"
That's mostly J-POP w
But ROCK is just something they declare themselves, right?
例えば東京五輪が決まって日本のバンドが出るとき
一番万人受けするミスチルに出て欲しい
It has to be MisChil.
If they decide which Japanese band should perform at the Tokyo Olympics, I want MisChil who's popular with the public to perform.
- 21: 名無しさん＠恐縮です 2013/06/12 18:32:09 ID:PDd4JhfpI
- >>12いまのとこEXILEかAKBで確定ですw
At this point, it looks like it'll be EXILE and AKB w
は？
>9th ONE OK ROCK - 136
HUH?
No Thee Michelle Gun Elephant? This is done for...
素人がやるとただのJ-POPランクになる
If you're choosing rock bands then you should make the rockers take the survey.
If amateurs are the ones who vote, it will just turn into a J-POP ranking.
B'z is rock? wwwwwwwwwww
But Spitz isn't even rock
BLANKEY should be 1st
ファンとしては少し悲しい。
ミッシェルやBUCK-TICKは良いと思う。
L'Arc haven't had any rock-sounding songs recently.
It makes me a bit sad as a fan.
I think Michelle and BUCK-TICK are good though.
1位2位が既にロックバンドじゃないんだけど…
Err, but 1st and 2nd aren't even rock bands...
ただミスチル、てめえはＪ-ＰＯＰだ
B'z is rock. If not, then Aerosmith isn't rock too.
But MisChil, you're J-POP.
When you say rock, it has to be the TIMERS. Now that's rock.
- 659: 名無しさん＠恐縮です 2013/06/12 20:19:41 ID:mbUCAzla0
- >>50俺は23'sのほうが好きだけど
今まで聞いてきた中で日本じゃ
唯一ロックだと思った
I actually prefer the 23's.
Of everything I've listened to in Japan, they're the only ones I consider as rock.
No Kinniku Shojotai?
アラフォーの人気投票だろ
But damn, the bands here are pretty old LOL
It looks like a popularity vote of people around their 40s.
No Orange Range? (´･ω･｀)
お前らの中ではロックってのは何か崇高なものなのかよ、、
Music with distorted guitars and straightforward drumbeats are considered rock.
Is rock some sort of subliminal entity to you guys?
I feel that foreigners would snicker at this ranking
How come THE YELLOW MONKEY isn't in it...
BOOM BOOM SATELLITES が無いランキングに意味は無い
There's no point in a ranking that doesn't include BOOM BOOM SATELLITES
- 89: 名無しさん＠恐縮です 2013/06/12 18:39:39 ID:DOBB30U1P
- >>79あれロックなの？Is that rock?
- 135: 名無しさん＠恐縮です 2013/06/12 18:45:40 ID:AvRWdJBO0
- >>79激しく同意
Agree so much
ONE OK ROCKって何ぞ？
LOUDNESS is the only answer here.
What the heck's up with ONE OK ROCK?
I really don't get the definition of rock.
Don't they just have to smash their guitars to be considered rock?
REBECCA's in there, but there's no JUDY and MARY, huh?
So what about Yuya san
- 140: 名無しさん＠恐縮です 2013/06/12 18:46:18 ID:vd31bJzL0
- >>134奴はロッケンロール部門
That guy's in the Rock and Roll division
バンドの定義としてのドラム、ベース、ギター、ボーカルが
いるバンドとしてなら
TOKIOだよな
Summing them all up as 'rock' can get really confusing.
If it's just a band with a drummer, bassist, guitarist, and vocalist then...
it has to be TOKIO.
BUCK-TICK入れろやｗ
LOUDNESSもないやん。
Why is SPITZ in there wwwwwwwwww
Include BUCK-TICK w
LOUDNESS isn't even in there.
This is an amateurish ranking because there's no Otokogumi
- 260: 名無しさん＠恐縮です 2013/06/12 19:00:40 ID:UEtTtHSM0
- >>165本物って認められないよね
They're not being accepted as "real", right?
The top should have gone to HAPPYEND
You can really tell with this ranking that the music industry ended in the '90s
People who live a "rock" kind of life won't vote in surveys like this!
There's no Yuratei...
コミック・バンドかと思ってた
So the Southern All Stars is a rock band? I thought they were a comical band.
I thought X was already forgotten about. They're still surprisingly putting up a good fight, huh.
書き込みしてるの見てなんだかなぁって気分になった一年前
A year ago, I felt weird when I saw a post on Yahoo which I think was done by a Jr. highschooler that went: "Who's Japan's number 1 rock band? I'd be happy if it was Uverworld"
2位 イエモン
3位 ブランキー
でいい
Should be:
1. Boowy
2. Yellow Monkey
3. Blankey
エアロスミスが知ったら絶対に訴えられるレベル。
But habitual copycats B'z is the shame of Japan.
Aerosmith will definitely sue them if they knew about it.
- 231: 名無しさん＠恐縮です 2013/06/12 18:56:41 ID:N9iGHAOf0
- >>210ツェッペリンとモトリーも訴訟参加させろと言っておりますZeppelin and Motley are saying "let us in on it too!"
So RC Succession is out of the rankings since they're in the hall of fame, huh
http://userserve-ak.last.fm/serve/500/6238301/RC+band.jpg
What's the point in a rock ranking without Eikichi Yazawa and Yuya Uchida?
ブルーハーツとかボーイとか何時で止まってるんだよ
What's this? Aren't the oldies the only ones who voted here?
Blue Hearts? Boowy? When did your clocks stop, eh?
『人間椅子』
に違いない。
19th is
Ningen Isu
no doubt about it.
知名度ランキングじゃね？
Rock band?
Isn't this a name value ranking?
ここ数年音楽業界が可哀想なのは間違いない。
It may not be rock, but I think this is a proper ranking.
But there's no mistake that the music industry has been in a poor state for the past few years now.
There's no point in a band ranking that has no Kinniku Shoujotai and Ningen Isu... w
- 319: 名無しさん＠恐縮です 2013/06/12 19:08:10 ID:DLz3zwaCO
- >>293全く同感
Totally agreed
RC Succession should be 1st by a landslide
- 479: 名無しさん＠恐縮です 2013/06/12 19:40:35 ID:SHpNdGng0
- >>316賛同する。
で、
タイマーズが2位やな
I agree.
Then the TIMERS should be 2nd.
- 486: 名無しさん＠恐縮です 2013/06/12 19:42:27 ID:xjOz+jKJ0
- >>479３位は23's？
And 23's in 3rd spot?
- 502: 名無しさん＠恐縮です 2013/06/12 19:45:25 ID:SHpNdGng0
- >>486よし！それに決定や！
Yes! Let's go with that!
2位以降は異義あり
Well, I understand B'z getting 1st.
I have objections from 2nd onwards, though.
この辺は時代考えたら実力ありすぎる
このレベルが２０年前にあったのは日本限定バンドでは凄い
BOOWY, Siam Shade, Seikimatsu.
When you think of these guys and the era they were in, they just had too much talent.
It's amazing that bands of this calibre already existed 20 years ago.
９位知らねえな
有名なのか＞？
I don't know the band in 9th spot.
Are they popular?
(Related post HERE)
- 411: 名無しさん＠恐縮です 2013/06/12 19:23:08 ID:pR0a0QBH0
- >>392森進一と森雅子の子供
The son of Shinichi and Masako Mori
http://livedoor.blogimg.jp/aoba_f/imgs/7/e/7e7765bb.jpg
- 417: 名無しさん＠恐縮です 2013/06/12 19:24:14 ID:eyyvBQV10
- >>392最近のロックバンドでは、多分ダントツ人気で売れてる。
あの、AKBだのジャニだのK-POPだのアニソンだのが上位占めてるオリコンにも食い込めるほど。
確かに声はいいし、歌も上手い。さすがはサラブレッドってとこ
I think they're the most popular one among all rock bands now.
They're even in the Oricon charts dominated by AKB, Johnny's, K-POP, and anime songs.
True, he has a good voice and he's a good singer. As expected of a man with a reputable pedigree.
- 429: 名無しさん＠恐縮です 2013/06/12 19:27:35 ID:BFAk5eY80
- >>417そうなんだ・・初めて聞いた時凄い声だと思ったわ。
森慎一独特の物を受け継いでるよね。
Is that so... Well, I did think that guy had an amazing voice the first time I heard him.
He's probably inherited that unique 'x-factor' which Shinichi Mori possessed.
この時点でミスチルは却下だろ。
It seems that the definition of rock is using guitars and bass to make the sound while avoiding electronically generated sounds.
This is enough to drop MisChil out of there.
20代～40代の平均像か
There's a lot of '80s~'90s bands in there.
The survey takers must be around 20~40 years old.
その次がサカナクションあたりかな
Well, ONE OK ROCK is the most popular one among the young bands we have.
Next is probably Sakanaction.
The ranking does feel rock
こういうランキングから開放させてあげれたらいいのになあ…
ロックティストが一番強かったのが低迷期だし、、
I don't think the MisChil members themselves are too particular with the label "rock".
I hope they can be set free from rankings like this.
And they sounded rock the most when they were at the low point of their career.
I'm relieved that Golden Bomber isn't in there
1位RCサクセセション
2位BOOWY
3位BUCK-TICK
4位ブルーハーツ
5位ミッシェルガンエレファント
My ranking
1 - RC Succession
2 - BOOWY
3 - BUCK-TICK
4 - BLUE HEARTS
5 - MICHELLE GUN ELEPHANT
2位 ルナシー
だろ
ロックなら
It should be
1 - X
2 - LUNA SEA
if we're talking about rock.
見たらズッこけたわ
I thought it would include bands like LOUDNESS, EARTHSHAKER, PINK CLOUD...
I just totally tripped when I saw the ranking.
THE HIGH-LOWSが入ってない。却下。
No THE HIGH-LOWS? Rejected.
- 564: 名無しさん＠恐縮です 2013/06/12 20:00:12 ID:pOW0v8gf0
- >>548ハイロウズはブルハよりいいなあ
認知度低いけど
HIGH-LOWS is better than the Blue Hearts.
Though they're not that popular.
あとはゴミ
Yellow Monkey should be 1st.
Everything else is trash.
上っ面だけみるな
There are a lot of people who don't consider SAS as rock, huh.
Don't just look at the surface.
まぁ今はロック自体勢いないし大多数に支持されるバンドはもう出てこないな
There aren't a lot of youngsters in there.
Well, it does seem like rock doesn't have momentum now, and I don't think there will be a band again that will be supported by a lot of people.
10～20代に聞いたら全然違うだろうな。
It's our generation, no matter how you look at it LOL
It probably would have been different if you asked 10~20 year olds.
現代のバンドがワンオクしかいないｗｗｗｗｗｗ
So old wwwwwwwwwwwww
ONE-OK's the only modern band in there wwwwwwwwww
- 643: 名無しさん＠恐縮です 2013/06/12 20:15:37 ID:RkWJ9NC70
- >>635つまり現代のバンドはワンオク以外駄目だと
Which also means that everything other than ONE OK is no good in the modern age
I don't really get it, but to me, rock is wearing leather jackets and looking mean.
Original Thread
http://awabi.2ch.net/test/read.cgi/mnewsplus/1371029327/
Download B'z music on iTunes
Download ONE OK ROCK music on iTunes
Shop for Mr. Children-related items on RAKUTEN
No comments:
Post a Comment